Scala's Try-Success-Failure for Java 8

This API is a Java 8 implementation of the Scala Try API, originally implemented by Twitter Engineers and later added to the Scala Standard Library.

The Try type represents a computation that may fail. If the computation is successful it returns the value wrapped in a Try.Success otherwise the java.lang.Exception wrapped in a Try.Failure.

In order to use Try you need to call the Try.apply(FailableSupplier) method providing a lambda with the same signature used for a common java.util.function.Supplier. Indeed FailableSupplier is just a java.util.function.Supplier with a throws Exception added to its get method.

Note that I'm not saying here that the try-catch approach must be abandoned in favour of Try-Success-Failure. Indeed there are cases where you would use the traditional try-catch pattern but, in general, I think this API provides a more fluent interface to deal with exceptions.

Using Try as a Maven dependency

Binary release artifacts are published to the Sonatype OSS Repository Hosting service. Add the following dependency into your pom.xml to use Try:

<dependency>
  <groupId>com.lambdista</groupId>
  <artifactId>try</artifactId>
  <version>0.1.0</version>
</dependency>

Build

This project is managed with Maven so it can be built using:

$ git clone https://github.com/lambdista/try.git
$ cd try
$ mvn package

You'll find the jar under the usual target directory.

Running the examples in source code

Using Maven and the exec-maven-plugin you can run the main classes representing the examples for this project. For instance, to run the ReadFileLines main class you can use:

$ mvn exec:java -Dexec.mainClass="com.lambdista.example.ReadFileLines"

The changing part is the full path to the main class you intend to run.

Examples

In order to get you acquainted with this API each example will be provided using both the same old try-catch pattern and the new Try API.

Example 1: Read a file line by line

As a first example consider the code you need to implement a method to read a file line by line in Java 8.

Using the traditional try-catch block

public static List<String> readFile(String file) {

    List<String> lines;
    try {
        lines = Files.readAllLines(new File(file).toPath());
    } catch (IOException e) {
        lines = Arrays.asList("Could not read the file: " + file);
    }

    return lines;
}

readFile reads the content of a file, line by line, into a List<String>. In case of exception the method returns a List<String> with just one line: "Could not read...".

Using the Try API

public static List<String> readFile(String file) {

    return Try.apply(() -> Files.readAllLines(new File(file).toPath()))
            .getOrElse(Arrays.asList("Could not read the file: " + file));

}

In this case a lambda is passed to Try.apply. The Try's getOrElse method returns the value obtained by the call to Files.readAllLines(new File(file).toPath()) if no exception is thrown or whatever you passed to it in case of exception. Of course everything is type safe, in the sense that getOrElse will accept only arguments whose type is the same of Try's. Thanks to the type inferer there's no need to specify the type for Try in the previous code. In fact, it is equivalent to Try.<List<String>>apply(() -> Files.readAllLines(new File(file).toPath())) where you explicitly say that the Try's type is List<String>.

Which version do you like more? The try-catch approach or the Try one? It may be a matter of taste or just because I'm used to it but I prefer the latter--also because otherwise I wouldn't have written this API! :-)

Example 2: Read the content of a URL into a String

Using the traditional try-catch-finally block

public static String urlToString(String url, String errorMessage) {
    Scanner scanner = null;
    try {
        scanner = new Scanner(new URL(url).openStream(), "UTF-8");
        String result = scanner.useDelimiter("\\A").next();
        scanner.close();
        return result;
    } catch (IOException e) {
        return errorMessage;
    } finally {
        if (scanner != null) {
            scanner.close();
        }
    }
}

urlToString reads the content of a URL into a String. The method takes two parameters: url which is the String representing the URL and errorMessage which is the String to return if the URL content retrieving fails. Notice the boilerplate code. You need to initialize the scanner reference to null. You also have to use a finally block and close the Scanner object after checking if it is not null. Wouldn't it be great if you could avoid such a boilerplate code and let an API do it for you? Well, take a look at the, semantically, same code in the following example.

Using the Try API

public static String urlToString(String url, String errorMessage) {
    Try<Scanner> scanner = Try.apply(() -> new Scanner(new URL(url).openStream(), "UTF-8"));
    String result = scanner.map(s -> s.useDelimiter("\\A").next()).getOrElse(errorMessage);
    scanner.forEach(s -> s.close());
    return result;
}

Look ma, no null initialization, no try-catch-finally block and no null check before closing scanner! The first line of the method creates a Try<Scanner> object which can be, as usual, a Success<Scanner> or a Failure<Scanner> depending on the result of the lambda. The map method is then used to transform it into a Try<String>, taking care of the fact that if the result of Try.apply is a Failure<Scanner> now it just becomes a Failure<String> otherwise it gets mapped into a Success<String>. getOrElse then extracts its content (a String) if it's a Success or returns errorMessage if it's a Failure. Afterward the forEach method takes care of closing the Scanner object if it is of type Success<Scanner> otherwise it does nothing. Finally the result is returned.

Typically you use map to transform something into something else, while you employ forEach to consume something, that is to use it someway. As a matter of fact forEach has a void return type.

The Try version is declarative whilst the try-catch-finally one is imperative. Expressing the Try version in words you have: "Try to create a Scanner object for the given URL. Afterward map this object into a String or else use this other String if it's a failure. In the end close the Scanner object."

Example 3: Integer division

This is an interesting one because it shows another peculiarity of the Try API. You may already know that Java has both checked and unchecked exceptions. For checked exceptions the compiler won't accept your code if you forget to handle them. However unchecked exceptions such as NullPointerException, IllegalArgumentException, RuntimeException and so on are not notified by the compiler if you don't handle them. Consider the following code snippet:

System.out.println("Enter the dividend press Return and then enter the divisor: ");
Scanner dividend = new Scanner(System.in);
Scanner divisor = new Scanner(System.in);

int num = dividend.nextInt();
int denum = divisor.nextInt();
String res = "The quotient is: " + (num / denum);
System.out.println(res);

The previous code asks the user to enter two integers and then performs their division. The problem is that it could throw two types of unchecked exceptions and the compiler of course wouldn't tell you. You are required to know it yourself. The two unchecked exceptions I'm talking about are java.util.InputMismatchException and java.lang.ArithmeticException if the user enter a non-integer or zero as the divisor, respectively. Now, if you have a decent mathematical background you know you can't divide by zero. Furthermore you can also imagine that Scanner's nextInt method may throw some type of exception if you enter a non-integer. However, in both cases you have to look up the type of exception. Yes, you can use a generic catch(Exception e) and capture them all if you're not interested in the specific type or you could avoid using try-catch in the first place thanks to Try. Here are both implementations.

Using the traditional try-catch block

public static void divideWithoutTry() {

    System.out.println("Enter the dividend press Return and then enter the divisor: ");
    Scanner dividend = new Scanner(System.in);
    Scanner divisor = new Scanner(System.in);

    String res;
    try {
        res = "The quotient is: " + (dividend.nextInt() / divisor.nextInt());
    } catch(InputMismatchException|ArithmeticException e) {
        res = "The integers you entered are not valid or the divisor is zero.";
    }

    System.out.println(res);
}

Using the Try API

public static void divideWithTry() {

    System.out.println("Enter the dividend press Return and then enter the divisor: ");
    Scanner dividend = new Scanner(System.in);
    Scanner divisor = new Scanner(System.in);

    String res = Try.apply(() -> dividend.nextInt() / divisor.nextInt())
            .map(quotient -> "The quotient is: " + quotient)
            .getOrElse("The integers you entered are not valid or the divisor is zero.");

    System.out.println(res);
}

In the previous code map maps the Integer result into a String. After the map call you have something that was a Try<Integer> transformed into a Try<String>. This is another important aspect of Try. Its type can be mapped into another type without the need to do explicit exception-handling in all of the places that an exception might occur. I mean if dividend.nextInt() / divisor.nextInt() caused an exception the result of Try.apply would be a Try.Failure instance. Nevertheless it's type would be Try<String>. This lets you call getOrElse passing a String to it.

Integer sum

An important property of Try is its ability to pipeline (chain if you prefer) operations, catching exceptions along the way thanks to its flatMap method. If you are not a functional programmer concepts such as flatMap/map might not be easy to grasp at first. However you'll get used to them when you become one and, in the end, you'll love them. Moreover you're going to encounter these methods more and more often since some important Java 8 classes already implement them (e.g. java.util.Optional and java.util.stream.Stream). Anyway for the moment just take for granted that to pipeline more than two operations, say N, you just need to chain them by using N - 1 flatMap calls and a last call to map. For example, suppose you have 3 variables--x, y and z--being of type Try<Integer> and you just want to sum them up. Here is the code you need:

x.flatMap(a -> y.flatMap(b -> z.map(c -> a + b + c)))

Apart from the methods seen in these examples, such as map, flatMap and getOrElse, Try has many other useful methods. See the TryTest class for a thorough coverage of all its methods.

Known differences with the original library

Exception handling

In Scala exceptions are all unchecked so when you use the get method you're not forced to deal with the exception it throws in case this Try object is a Failure. In order to reflect this behaviour, calling get on Failure objects will throw a GetOfFailureException which wraps the original Exception. Since GetOfFailureException is unchecked you're not forced to handle it. However, if for some reason you need to deal with checked exceptions this API provides a further method, checkedGet, which may throw an Exception that must be handled.

As a final note, the original library traps Throwable objects. This means that it also handles errors which are a subclass of Error. In general you should not catch Errors. As a matter of fact, the Java API describes Error starting with the following definition: "An Error is a subclass of Throwable that indicates serious problems that a reasonable application should not try to catch". For this reason I decided not to catch Throwables but only Exceptions.

Javadoc

API documentation for this project.

Bugs and Feedback

For bugs, questions and discussions please use the Github Issues.

License

Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the "License"); you may not use this file except in compliance with the License. You may obtain a copy of the License at

http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0

Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS, WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied. See the License for the specific language governing permissions and limitations under the License.

try

Implementation of the Try-Success-Failure Scala API for Java 8

Scala's Try-Success-Failure for Java 8

Using Try as a Maven dependency

Build

Running the examples in source code

Examples

Example 1: Read a file line by line

Using the traditional try-catch block

Using the Try API

Example 2: Read the content of a URL into a String

Using the traditional try-catch-finally block

Using the Try API

Example 3: Integer division

Using the traditional try-catch block

Using the Try API

Integer sum

Known differences with the original library

Exception handling

Javadoc

Bugs and Feedback

License

Credits